Carlo`s Restaurant in New Rochelle

Super delicious food. I passed by this restaurant a million times and finally decided to try it out. Hands down one of the best Italian restaurants in New Rochelle!

Delicious dinner, excellent staff

Went to Carlo's for my first time for my birthday and everything we ate was incredible! We will be back soon

Food was great! Service was great! The penne vodka was amazing! The calamari was OMG! And wait there’s more, the tiramisu was AMAZING!!!! Definitely try this place. Great atmosphere too.

This place used to be amazing. I'm not sure what has happened but the food has certainly slipped

The Food is pretty delicious. Best Tiramisu ever! However the waiters are a bit slow when picking the check. Overall We had a great time.

Love Carlos restaurant NR since day one have to try the original in Yonkers soon thanks Carlos for being part of New Rochelle 👍🇺🇸

Excellent food and cozy atmosphere

Great food. Love the shrimp parmesan! Outdoor seating for lunch is great in the warmer weather.

Fantastic food love the pizza. Amazing service

Great place to go for a great meal with a nice atmosphere the host makes sure your well attended to food is fresh priced right only thing I feel there are to many people working on the floor to serve you and don't speak or understand much in English mks it hard to ask for things but that is a minor thing everyone is polite and attentive and everything is fresh and desserts are amazing definitely will be back. A must to try if you are looking for good Italian food a must to go to ty

Food is good but customer service sucks. Called them every hour for couple hour just to hear they are ten minutes away turning into me being told my order was delivered to another address and the person (who didn’t order this) accepted and paid for a meal that randomly showed up so of course we had to order elsewhere... oh an that other address they said they delivered it to I check and it doesn’t exist until 356 miles away... this bs came from the “manager “ who supposedly was the one delivering my food himself after the first hour late 🙈🤷‍♂️💩

the food was delicious service was good

Great service and amazing food

Great place to escape the everyday hustle!! Great ambiance,, excellent food and staff!!! Would highly recommend Carlos!!!

Whatta dagon shame?! WTH hapd here such a disillusionment; wherein quality met quantity. The # is disconnected, the website cannot be found, all lights are out @ the locale - like no movement whatsoever. Soo howzabout AJs tonight again then hunny: we forgot to take the meat out afterall?! Rrr

I was a frequent customer at Carlos' Yonkers location 40 years ago. When they opened this New Rochelle location I was thrilled. And they do not disappoint. Clearly their menu has evolved, and the quality of their food is still impeccable. The staff is welcoming, helpful, and friendly. And the vibe is hip and comfy at the same time.

Great place to eat ..very cozy ...good service and food .

Delicious food. Ample portions. Hood service!!! Highly recommend.

This place has stood the test of time and still gives good quality Italian food and the pizzas are also very good. We use them for delivery sometimes too and they’re just as good.

Great food and great service Easter

Nothing they make is outside of the deliciousness that makes this place one of my faves!

This is a great place - super friendly staff, excellent food, excellent service.

Absolutely, the best Italian food we have ever had!! Every meal was prepared to perfection! We were so fortunate to have our son's communion celebration here! My entire family from all over the globe came together for this day and everyone so impressed with the food, service and atmosphere. Thank you to the owners who treated us like their family.

A good Italian joint, the food was good and the portions were healthy. They we're able to accommodate a party of 11 without difficulty.

Nice atmosphere, food was delicious and large portions.

Good customer service. Food was delicious

Absolutely a spot worth trying, the food is great and fresh, the prices are affordable and it is always clean in here. Keep up the good work.

Great service and food

Great food and good lunch specials.

Loved the ambience, kid-friendly. The waiters were pleasant. The kale salad wasn't all that but the roast chicken and potatoes was super. Together with some cocktails made for a great night out for under $80.

First visit to this location of Carlo's restaurant in New Rochelle and what a great dinner. So many appetizing choices on the menu that we are going to have to go back a few times to taste everything! Had the eggplant appetizer and it was delicious. Great place to eat outside on a warm night too even though it's on a main street it's very charming to sit outside. It's small inside so I have heard there can be a wait at times. Will definitely be returning !!

Food is consistently good. Service is hit or miss. Mostly miss. After going there regularly for weeks after they opened, the quality of service was declining. Food also came out late, cold and not so good that night. Bad combination. Starting going elsewhere. Finally gave them a shot again after more than a year. Food was very good. We're not demanding customers, but again the waitress was terrible. Talking over us, not listening to responses or questions. Disappearing for long periods of time. Probably not going back despite high quality food. Maybe I would consider for take-out to eliminate service aspect.

Food was amazing, service was exemplary. We got the two vegetarian pasta dishes and the kale side dish and I was tempted to lick my plate :) All of our servers were super friendly, and paced our meal just right. Definitely one of my new favorite New Rochelle restaurants!

They have so many delicious choices it's hard to pick which one to have

Food was good and service was excellent. We live in Astoria, but we regularly make the trip just to eat their delicious food. Their pizza is great and the pasta is out of their world.

Great service the food was amazing the drinks were absolutely delicious I really recommend this place

Can’t go wrong with anything you order here...salads, chicken parm, pizza! All good

Good Italian menu.Thin tasty pizza. Well priced. Parking indoors next to restaurant. Very busy on weekends. Reservations suggested. Service spotty on weekends.

Wonderful service fresh food and fantastic ambiance. Went with my sister for the first time and was amazing pleased.

Great local Italian place

Ate outdoors. So charming. Quiet, delicious meal.

I come here often and have never had a bad experience. Highly recommend

Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, good food. Pretty much everything I look for in a restaurant. Parking is usually pretty good as well considering the area.

Food was absolutely boring, tasteless and ill prepared. Never had pasta fagioli without beans and pasta. WTH???!! ABSOLUTELY TASTELESS AND PLAIN WRONG!! The chicken francese was tasteless as well. I ate it because I was starving. This was on St. Patrick's Day and they gave us a sample of their pizza with corned beef and sauerkraut & mustard. In all fairness, that was the best food we had eaten! I guess this is just a fancy pizzeria.

I like this venue very much. It has a nice spirit. The meals are tasty. the service is powerful and the stuff is friendly. The cost is fair. greatly recommend.

I loved this place. I am so sad to have learned they closed down :(

Westchester’s Best Chicken Parm!

I love this place..I've been there few times and always same quality food and great service. I'm a fan of mussels I love their fra diavolo mussels and regular cheese pizza in the brick oven..

Worst pizza I ever ate. This is supposed to be a Margarita--"Pizza Margherita is a typical Neapolitan pizza, made with San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, salt and extra-virgin olive oil." I got ZERO tomatoes, practically no basil, and barely enough sauce to cover the crust. For this I broke my diet. Oh well.